View Single Post
Old 05-04-2012, 12:53 PM   #24
pcmusicpro
Human being with feelings
 
pcmusicpro's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2010
Location: Cali, Colombia.
Posts: 630
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Reno.thestraws View Post
totally agreed!

And as I say... you listen to A SONG

a song might sound good or not because of the production but there are a million factor's that influence that

tracking
arrangement
musician plays
intruments
mix
phase
etc
etc

the summing (analog or digital) represent nothing in that vortex of possibilities

the proof?

do the ABX test in double blind on 100 percent, you'll see that nobody could make a 10/10


I don't say that analog summing is the same that digital but it's not really important! it's just a matter of habit of work!

and if you don't know waht you want

do a real comparaison test with no other variables!

Because this test is not a real one

imagine you wanna compare a old analog camera with a digital one

- you take a picture of a landscape with digital camera
- diplay thaht picture on a super high resolution monitor
- take a picture of the monitor with the old camera .
- compare the pics...
Don't get upset, just play along with the initial intention of the post, it's no a scientific test, it's just two ways of doing the same thing which is summing some audio stems ITB and OTB and comment about it. The test can be as subjective as a poem and that is not bad. Just answer the question: which one did you liked the most and why? if you don't like it it's ok too.

Salut!

Ed.
pcmusicpro is offline   Reply With Quote