Originally Posted by REAmix
I personally think that replacing anything with something else goes against the spirit of the whole thing.
The whole point, to me, is to do a mix with the same content and the same tools.
im with you
i post the mix too late, sorry, but anyway i would like to receive some critics
i think im ID11
some of my points for the other ones:
ID1: the voice level is a quite bit lower. the main guitars in the verse part was lower too, and the shaker too loud.
ID2: like this mix.. perhaps the guitars are a quit bit lower. balanced at well.
ID4: drums sound ok, the snare a little machine style.. the bass eq doesn´t convince me. too much reverb in the voice.
ID5: in the verse could be possible that the tracks delayed between?. like the voice.
ID6: too much compresion in the instruments, specially drums? the voice eq is separated from the rest, also.
ID7: sounds good, but the replacement on the instruments...
ID8: like the final EQ, but the guitar section is a quite bit lower. anyway i like.
ID9: like this,accurate and balanced.
ID10: like this, balanced, the shaker is loud. like the final EQ of the song.
i didn´t time to vote, but this was my appreciation of the mixes.
about this, my votes are for ID9, ID10 & ID2