Quote:
Originally Posted by Judders
For me, I prefer the first version.
The bass was really driving it before, and now it sounds a little lacklustre, lacking energy. I love the vocal delivery, but I think it only works if it's buried a little bit.
While technically you've got a balance that makes the parts generally clearer in the new version, I find that it has lost some oomph.
I like the idea of a fuzz solo, but the first solo had more of a melodic journey to it, and I think musically served the song better.
That low organ is a nice touch though.
|
Hey Judders. Gotta find that balance between going by my own instincts and by the suggestion of other ears, even if a bit exaggerated. Mix-wise, I do prefer elements of the first version myself, but I do try to stay open to improvements too.
Quote:
Originally Posted by kirk1701
To wit. Sorry Sam. I think I killed your song
|
Not in the least man. You had nothing to do with the mix, and as for the lead, I really like both for different reasons--not "just saying that." I can say yours was a LOT easier to fit in. It took hardly any time at all. I'm saving both versions of the project.