Cinematic Studio Strings vs Real Orchestra

[Dzirka]

I have a riddle for you. Here is a short sample of the song in two versions A and B. One of these versions is a midi orchestra, created using Cinematic Studio Strings, and next to that is a version recorded by a live reputable orchestra in Japan. Which version is which? I'm curious to hear the answers.

[prom]

1st real 2nd midi

[Tod]

Originally Posted by Dzirka

I have a riddle for you. Here is a short sample of the song in two versions A and B. One of these versions is a midi orchestra, created using Cinematic Studio Strings, and next to that is a version recorded by a live reputable orchestra in Japan. Which version is which? I'm curious to hear the answers.

I agree with prom, in the first I can hear the room, in the 2nd the violins and cellos are more panned, left & Right.

Well done though Dzirka, and well done enough I guess we could be wrong.

[Dzirka]

Thanks, Prom and Tod. I'll wait to see if anyone else joins in the guessing.

[Dzirka]

So I thought the riddle would attract more people.. hihi. I'll wait till tomorrow and then I'll tell you the result.

[Dzirka]

Okay, the attempt to create a suspenseful riddle failed. But thanks to the two participants. "A" is the orchestra. So everyone guessed correctly. That's not the case on my Facebook page, where there were about 50 people guessing and only a few of them got it right.

[Tod]

Originally Posted by Dzirka

Okay, the attempt to create a suspenseful riddle failed. But thanks to the two participants. "A" is the orchestra. So everyone guessed correctly. That's not the case on my Facebook page, where there were about 50 people guessing and only a few of them got it right.

There's nothing wrong with what you did with midi Dzirka.