[FIXED] Notation bug - window resize bug

[bFooz]

- open notation in a window
- stretch notation's window horizontally

BUG - notation itself is stretched horizontally and even changes zoom level

EXPECTED - only the window is stretched, revealing/concealing its content


Current Reaper:



Compare it with how e.g. Sonar does this:



More issues described by another user in a further post in this thread:
https://forum.cockos.com/showpost.ph...9&postcount=11

Related:
https://forum.cockos.com/showthread....69#post2442869

[ivansc]

That is normal behaviour.

Try using the zoom arrows to set how big or small you want the bars displayed, then use the Reaper scroll button in the same way you are trying to use the windows handle.
The problem here is that you are trying to use a windows-specific action to affect a Reaper-specific function.

Think of it as working in exactly the same way that scrolling works in all the other MIDI editors & it will all become clear.

P.S. As far as I am aware, this is exactly how all other DAWs do it. Certainly Cakewalk Sonar, Studio One and Logic do it that way.
So not a Reaper bug as such.

[bFooz]

I have not used any other DAW for notation, but this looks unintuitive. The MIDI editor in Reaper does not stretch anyhting, it reveals, so I think notation editor should behave the same.

Plus there is this thing with zooming, X and Y zoom axis are not independent: https://forum.cockos.com/showthread.php?t=209877 . Which again I think they should behave like zooming in MIDI editor or arrange.

[ivansc]

I have used notation editors in other programs since the 1990s.
The only real difference is that under AmigaOS separate windows were instantiated by the program being used & not using the OS windowing as is the case in your example.

You appear to be confusing the two states.

Within Reaper`s actual MIDI editing system, you can achieve the result you expect by using the provided tools, including Reapers own built in controls.
And if you use them, you DO have control over the X& Y axes independently.

Maybe time to check out the User Guide in detail as to how the editor controls work in general, because they are identical for all MIDI editing windows, which of course is what the notation editor is under the surface.

[ivansc]

A quick PS: since the majority of things you have queried in your other posts ARE bugs, thanks from the rest of us for your efforts.
Wish I was as good at spotting stuff like the bugs you HAVE found.

[bFooz]

Originally Posted by ivansc

Certainly Cakewalk Sonar, Studio One and Logic do it that way.

There must be some misunderstanding, because Sonar (Cakewalk by Bandlab) does not stretch, it reveals.




If this Reaper's stretching was useful to you, how then?

[ivansc]

Cant see all of the window you are moving but from what I see here it looks like you are moving the actual window position in an dout, not the locastion of the window on the track itself. So fdrustrating when we are not sitting side by side at the same computer!

I will go re-check in Sonar.

O.K. MY cakewalk by Bandlab windows look and act nothing like yours.

It looks like you are instantiating OS windows with the notation editor in them & then moving the whole window left or right.

Headscratch moment here.
MY notation editor is already in a separate Cakewalk window & can indeed be scrolled along by using the gadget at the bottom of the window. Exactly as I can do in Reaper.
I will figure out doing a screen shot if I can.

O.K. I just opened the same project in Cakewalk and Reaper. In Notation view, BOTH programs operate in the same way.

At the bottom of the notation view, there is a scrolling handle that enables you to scroll left or right through the track.
I can`t see the bottom of your notation window in your first screenshot, but if you look, you will see a scroll tool or handle that enables you to grab it and scroll back and forth through the track.
As I said in the beginning, the mistake you are making is trying to use the parent OS window to scroll, not the actual program.
You appear to be doing the same in Cakewalk, FWIW.

Might be worth revisiting some of Kenny Gioia`s free videos to actually watch someone editing notation. Hard to explain in words & like I said I havent ever done a screen shot "movie".

[bFooz]

Originally Posted by ivansc

Cant see all of the window you are moving but from what I see here it looks like you are moving the actual window position in an dout, not the locastion of the window on the track itself. So fdrustrating when we are not sitting side by side at the same computer!

I will go re-check in Sonar.

O.K. MY cakewalk by Bandlab windows look and act nothing like yours.

It looks like you are instantiating OS windows with the notation editor in them & then moving the whole window left or right.

Headscratch moment here.
MY notation editor is already in a separate Cakewalk window & can indeed be scrolled along by using the gadget at the bottom of the window. Exactly as I can do in Reaper.
I will figure out doing a screen shot if I can.

O.K. I just opened the same project in Cakewalk and Reaper. In Notation view, BOTH programs operate in the same way.

At the bottom of the notation view, there is a scrolling handle that enables you to scroll left or right through the track.
I can`t see the bottom of your notation window in your first screenshot, but if you look, you will see a scroll tool or handle that enables you to grab it and scroll back and forth through the track.
As I said in the beginning, the mistake you are making is trying to use the parent OS window to scroll, not the actual program.
You appear to be doing the same in Cakewalk, FWIW.

Might be worth revisiting some of Kenny Gioia`s free videos to actually watch someone editing notation. Hard to explain in words & like I said I havent ever done a screen shot "movie".

In those gifs of mine, scrolling is not my intention. My intention is to show how the notation is weirdly stretched in Reaper and just normally revealed in Sonar. Scrolling by resizing a window was never the goal of this post, the misunderstanding probably lies there.

Also if you could make some gifs, that would be great. (Here is a tool for that if you happen not to now it https://www.cockos.com/licecap/)

[ivansc]

Did you actually try doing what I suggested with the scroll handle?
And yes I am beginning to wonder if I am completely mis-interpreting what you want to achieve.
BUT I can do exactly what you are apparently unable to do in Reaper,. just the same way as in Sonar.
Will do a licecap when I have time, which will be a few days as my brother is in the UK visiting from Florida.